Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When I first started using git years ago as a beginner to programming, I always wondered why it didn't just work this way. Since then I've just gotten so used to it that I forgot about my desire for it.

My hacky solution at the time was just to always do anything programming related in a folder watched by Dropbox. Then every single file modification and delta is indeed automatically stored (and away from my machine, for redundancy and safety). It's not the greatest UX when I occasionally dig through the Dropbox file modification history, but it works okay enough.

As an amateur musician, I always wondered why there wasn't any DAW that supported something like this, too. You get an endless undo button that automatically tracks all atomic actions (twist X knob to N%, change Y volume to N dB) to allow for reversions, but no system to actually view, restore, tag, or switch between anything in this edit tree beyond resorting to annoying kluges like "stashing" an older state by spam-clicking "undo", saving a copy of the project under a new file name with a short description of the state at that time, and then pressing "redo" over and over until you're back at the "present".

And when you close the program, all that undo history is gone, in which case if I feel like I did something that really messed up the whole project and which I want to revert, I have to dig through the Dropbox file edit history and download like 10 different copies of the project file around the time I think the undesirable change may have occurred, and load each project one by one to try to find the one that's immediately before that change.

Sorry for the long tangent. I just also don't see why this isn't already a thing for both source code and music project version control.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: