Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Curious to know what software the high-end VFX studios use. I'd just assumed most places were using adobe software.


Maya (modelling,UVing,layout,anim,rigging), Houdini (everything these days, but simulation/layout strongly), Nuke (compositing), Katana (scene management and rendering/lighting), Mari (texture painting).

Most packages (other than things like ZBrush) have Linux versions. Some packages originally were Linux only (Mari - although it had a Mac version at Weta that was discontinued for a bit and then brought back to life in 2013) and Katana (now has a Windows version).

Most of the commercial production VFX/CG renderers (Renderman, Arnold, VRay) have linux versions, and some of the proprietary ones (Manuka, Hyperion - I think?) are Linux only (only need to be used by the studio themselves).


Is there anywhere one could see an example of these tools being used together in and end-to-end workflow to get a quick sense of what VFX tools are capable of these days? It's a total black box to me, and I have no interest in it beyond the sheer curiosity of how far the tools have advanced and how much one can do with those with enough experience and effort.


Not really sure I understand what you're after...

If you're after what the software is capable of, then looking at the films to some degree is obviously the Litmus test :), but more usefully VFX breakdown videos might be useful or demos of the software described.

I can give you some links to breakdowns the studio I work for worked on, but unless you know the software to some degree, it's probably a bit too fast to really understand exactly what the software is doing, and doesn't really show the software being interactive with or used, but:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKtis34i8AM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ye7arp5IrAg

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAzm3LUvYWA


Yeah, if you're looking for workflow tutorials with specific tools, it'll be a bit more difficult since a lot of really big shops will roll some of their own tools between big commercial offerings like Lightworks, Resolve, Blackmagic Fusion, and the handful of very prominent open-source tools like Natron and Blender. Every project is going to be both chaotic on some level, and kind of protective of specifics.

Pixar in the past has been pretty open about their workflows, but those workflows are also full of their own tooling and technologies, a lot of which they've open-sourced: https://github.com/PixarAnimationStudios (cf. this 2020 interview with Nick Porcino, which calls out some things about open source: https://www.aswf.io/bts/nick-porcino-pixar/ )

Oh hey, speak of the devil, ASWF just put out a report a couple weeks ago about open source in entertainment: http://report.aswf.io/ (PDF)


You can check http://vfxplatform.com/, which is a high-level attempt to provide at least guidelines for a reference platform, and this SIGGRAPH 2021 presentation by Nick Cannon (Disney) and Francois Chardavoine (Lucasfilm/ILM) on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4tXrtJBqK0


You left out Houdini and Nuke!

I just think these two are too big to leave out.


I didn't? I mentioned them? I'd never leave out Nuke, as I used to help develop it... :)

I did leave out stuff like ZBrush (modelling, sculpting), Sihouette (Roto) and Camera Tracking stuff though :)

There's also an insane amount of proprietary software as well developed in house...


You are not alone, the strong marketing from Adobe and Apple creates the impression that image creators are all about having Adobe software on the latest Macs. This is far from the reality. While most don’t correlate Linux with artists, we can argue that the most impressive and sophisticated computer imagery is mostly created under this platform. Actually, even when the studio is mostly Windows based, after a certain size, it gradually moves to Linux, like Scanline.


Maya, 3ds max, Houdini, After Effects, Nuke, Mari, Katana, Vray, Arnold, Renderman, Clarisse, Modo, Substance, Zbrush, Cinema 4D

https://www.technowifi.com/software/video-editing/visual-eff...


The https://vfxplatform.com/ project is really interesting. From the FAQ:

> we have the enthusiastic support of all of the major application providers for the visual effects and animation industry, including Autodesk, The Foundry and Side Effects Software. [...] Linux is prevalent in VFX, particularly in the larger studios where they build sophisticated automation pipelines that integrate multiple different software vendors’ products together.


Blender has a large market share. Other tools like renderman are used. Painting software such as Krita and others but Photoshop and Substance Painter are still king (windows). Unreal engine is gaining a lot of traction in the VFX digital set space.


Blender's not really used at the high-end facilities... It doesn't really scale that well on large scenes, and only had a Python3 API - VFX studios have only really moved to Python 3 this year.


While this is true it is also changing. Studios are starting to allow Blender.

But yes, only since Blender 2.8 it came in the spotlight and adoption is slow.


Do we count the work behind latest Evangelion movie as high-end? Because IIRC they openly talked about using Blender in increasing amounts and sponsoring Blender foundation because of that.


I do wonder about that: it was also criticized for its jarring 3D effects (arguably, some of it due to artistic choices, but clearly not all of it), to the point where it was hot-fixed while it was still shown in theaters. So it might not be the advertising you might want for Blender.

But it might also be the consequence of its flawed production process.


Blender was used for other big films as well. But it is still not an industry standard. But that might change very soon.


When CinePaint became a big thing in Hollywood, its major rival was... Photoshop on Wine.


In a past lifetime I was a big user of Fusion. A limited version is these days free as part of DaVinci Resolve. I think the paid version is only $300. Quite a good deal for such a powerful tool. Fusion can be used alongside with its friends After Effects, Nuke, Flame


There is an official reference platform on the industry, https://vfxplatform.com/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: