Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is pretty obviously no. API keys billed by the token, yes, Oauth to the flat rate plans no.

> OAuth authentication (used with Free, Pro, and Max plans) is intended exclusively for Claude Code and Claude.ai. Using OAuth tokens obtained through Claude Free, Pro, or Max accounts in any other product, tool, or service — including the Agent SDK — is not permitted and constitutes a violation of the Consumer Terms of Service.



If you look at this tweet [1] and in particular responses under it, it still seems to me like some parts of it need additional clarification. For instance, I have seen some people interpret the tweet as meaning using the OAuth token is actually ok for personal experimentation with the Agent SDK, which can be seen as a slight contradiction with what you quoted. A parent tweet also mentioned the docs clean up causing some confusion.

None of this is legal advice, I'm just trying to understand what exactly is allowed or not.

[1] https://x.com/trq212/status/2024212380142752025?s=10


Read the actual ToS. What you describe is NOT allowed.


That tweet is from a product leader on Claude Code itself...


A tweet is not a ToS.


Then they should speak to legal about fixing the ToS before making public statements about their intentions with it. It won't look good to show up at arbitration and have to explain why your public comms contradict your ToS.


What flatrate?

Pro and Max are both limited


Flat rate does not imply unlimited.


>A flat fee, also referred to as a flat rate or a linear rate refers to a pricing structure that charges a single fixed fee for a service, regardless of usage.


That's one definition. There are others.

I'm sure you can use context clues to figure this one out. You're so close! Just put the pieces together.


There are no other definitions that‘s why they why internet flat rates got throttled instead of capped. Throttling is the loop bole because you paid for usage not for speed but flat rate with a cap is simply a lie.


What else would it mean?


That you are buying a bundle and it doesnt matter how much of the bundle you use you pay the same amount every billing period?


So if I buy entry to the swimming hall that allows me to be there for 4 hours but also allows me to leave earlier you would call that a flat rate?

I have never noticed there are people who interpret it that way.


If it allows you 4 hours total per month yea


That you are charged a single fixed fee regardless of usage.

Nothing about that prevents a usage cap.


A cap pretty much is the opposite of regardless of usage




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: